A few days ago I started reading Harlan Coben’s The Stranger. a friend had given me the crime thriller in anticipation of Richard Armitage starring in the Netflix adaptation, but I never got around to reading it. I watched the Netflix television series when it was originally released but I found it too chaotic, like a slippery fish that I just couldn’t hold on to. so when I started reading the book on a whim, I was not expecting much, just hoping that maybe the story would be more enjoyable to follow in written form. surprisingly, I couldn’t put it down!
I vaguely remembered the plot and the key players from the television series, so I already knew ‘who done it’ in the end but as it went along, I thought maybe I was misremembering because there were a lot of things that were different. a lot. the most glaring being the absence of the alpacas. not that I lamented this discrepancy, because it was essentially that whole tangent that turned me off the series, but did I mix up that whole teens getting high in the woods and decapitating an alpaca and then hiding it in the closet scenario? was that a Black Mirror episode?
When I finished the novel (in 2 days) my immediate reaction was that it made so much more sense! I then googled the ‘series vs the book’ to see if my memory was playing tricks on me (it wasn’t). I learned that the author wanted to switch things up in the tv version so that the book readers wouldn’t have it all figured out already. maybe viewers found all the switch ups exciting, and the story did have to be drawn out due to the series format instead of a one-time telling in movie form, but I think the book version worked better. all the drama of the high school subplot and the connection through Adam’s dad concerning the real estate war and the identity of the stranger, not to mention the revelation of why Adam’s older client didn’t want to move out of his house; it was just too much. I preferred the more straight forward explanations of the book.
I also learned that the author’s young daughter is responsible for the whole alpaca sideshow. and now that makes more sense too.
I’d like to read other Harlan Coben books but don’t know which one to try next. Richard Armitage is set to appear in an adaptation of Stay Close; should I read that one or try some others first?